' ' Cinema Romantico: Some Drivel On...the next James Bond

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Some Drivel On...the next James Bond

New James Bond on the right, not the left.

When “Casino Royale” was released 20 years ago this month, and I was still a twentysomething dum-dum, I gave it a withering review in which I complained about Daniel Craig’s version of James Bond not being the right version of James Bond. And gawd, was that a boring take. No wonder I don’t listen to critics (like me)! What do they (me) know?! What was the “right” Bond I was referring to anyway? I didn’t even define it, exactly. Roger Moore is who I meant, probably, who isn’t my favorite Bond, per se, because I don’t claim to have a favorite Bond, but because he was 007 in my favorite Bond movie – “The Spy Who Loved Me.” But that’s the thing with a role like Bond, who began as a character in books, and then segued into a character in movies, but a movie character played by several different actors, all of whom were providing different interpretations, albeit while all reverting to His Majesty’s Secret Service mean. We all have different ideas of what Bond should be and they are all rooted in some version of what came before.

I had honestly stopped caring about new Bonds a long time ago. If I addressed the topic on the blog, it was only in a comically unserious manner. You think it should be Idris Elba? Sure, sounds good to me. You think it should be Josh O’Connor? Why not, he seems capable of just about anything. You think it should be Callum Turner? Hey, I trust Dua Lipa’s taste. Over time, I have come to realize that an actor’s performance is shaped as much by a director or is shaped by an actor harmonizing with a director. In the case of James Bond, however, an actor’s performance is shaped by the role. Daniel Craig was a little rougher around the edges, but he was still painting within rigid lines. Even if the part had gone to Emily Blunt, for whom The New Yorker’s Anthony Lane made a compelling case, regardless of the one obvious difference, she would have been painting between them too. And then on Monday the franchise decided to enlist Robert Pattinson.

Why did it choose him? Well, because he’s English, of course, and devastatingly handsome, as Sloane Peterson once described the Sausage King of Chicago, and also because he’s bankable, I’m sure, a globally famous actor who helped front the “Twilight” series way back when and in its first go-around with this venerable franchise, Amazon MGM wants someone famous as the face. Yet, Pattinson has proven himself an agreeably eccentric actor, in his choices but also in his style, prone to not giving you what you expect. That does often correlate to the directors he is working with, an impressively disparate collection of, among others, Claire Denis, David Cronenberg, Bong Joon Ho, James Gray, and the Safdie Brothers; he knows how to harmonize with an auteur’s intent. But as he just proved in “The Odyssey,” injecting some humor into Christopher Nolan’s otherwise unsurprisingly humorless version, he also retains the ability to sort of emotionally extemporize, to zig when others zag. Maybe he’ll take Amazon MGM’s orders, but maybe he’ll color outside the lines. Maybe his interpretation won’t be exactly what I want, or what you want, or what anyone else wants, and if it isn’t, well, that would be my preference.