“You Can See Everything” was co-directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, the former having made a name for himself in various TV shows and streaming series as a metatextual comedian, bringing that sensibility with him to this fast-moving 174-minute movie. Indeed, if many modern documentaries tend to be made not just with the explicit participation of their subjects, but even with those subjects sometimes acting as producers, it reduces the filmmaker(s) to working on behalf of their subjects rather than the other way around. And though you see Holmes and Evans effectively trying to launder not only Holmes’s recalibrated image but their pitch for a Theranos 2.0 through “You Can See Everything,” Fielder and Oppenheim refuse such exploitation. Fielder is an on-screen presence throughout and the first time we see him peering at Holmes and Evans through a window, the image essentially manifests the fly on the wall adage of observational documentaries before Fielder rather swiftly metamorphoses into a fly in the ointment of a participatory one instead.
That is why “You Can See Everything” eschews talking head interviews to instead show Fielder probing Holmes and Evans in a series of on-camera conversations. In his uniquely disarming deadpan, Fielder often comes across like a comic version of The New Yorker’s Isaac Chotiner, who has made a name for himself by gently backing so many arrogant interview subjects into corners. By showing it this way, “You Can See Everything” visually demonstrates the distinct push and pull between the filmmakers and the subjects, a dynamic that most documentaries would be keen to leave out. At one point, we see Evans nude in the shower, which feels like Evans graphically asserting control as only a male who later brags about his sexual expertise might. He insists on radical transparency, but he also occasionally insists that the cameras be turned off when a subject he does not want to discuss is broached. To his credit, Fielder does not excise his own intentional maneuvering from the screen. When he presents Holmes with a gag gift before she leaves to start her prison sentence, it feels less like an off the cuff moment than a pre-planned comedy bit, evocative of myriad moments sprinkled throughout where you detect him setting up and then seeing through a joke. Both sides have an agenda.
Yet, despite his own intentionality, Fielder expresses a genuine fear of being scammed by Holmes a la the rest of the business world. Though he concedes his lack of scientific knowledge, he asks her pointed questions about the key Theranos blood-testing device and finds himself caught in an awe-inspiring loop of Holme’s circular logic of self-professed innocence born of misunderstanding that, itself, yields linguistic misinterpretation between her and Fielder in a way evoking nothing less than Abbott and Costello’s famed Who’s on First routine. In response, Fielder literally plays her a clip of the routine, and afterwards, Holmes claims not to really get the joke. Like so many moments in “You Can See Everything,” it reminded me of Billy Bob Thortnon as “Bad Santa” staring down a blank-faced Thurman Merman and exhorting him, “Are you fucking with me?” Is Elizabeth Holmes fucking with Nathan Fielder, or is she an open book written in a language that no can quite decipher? It’s impossible to know, and the close-ups that Fielder and Oppenheimer routinely deploy, the soft lighting seeming to intensify the pupils of Holmes, feels like the filmmakers doing their level best to burrow deep into her soul to uncover whether she is or not.
A key recurring bit becomes a 2023 New York Times profile in which Holmes claims she was misquoted. “They’re not playing me,” the paper of record quotes her as saying of Amanda Seyfried and others who have portrayed Holmes on screen in various capacities, “they’re playing a character I created.” Holmes insists the “I” was a “they,” that she, herself, was never playing a character and everyone else, us, assumed she was. She and Evans even claim to have proof of the real quote, though it is never shared, just as the Times never provides its own evidence except to say it stands by its story, standard operating procedure. Fielder seeks confirmation of this detail, as if might prove the key that turns the lock, but in something as dazzlingly disorienting as “You Can See Everything,” no dice. Instead, just as this near three-hour movie seems to be hitting a dead end as Holmes reports to prison, Fielder and Oppenheim manufacture a way to explore the tension between that quote in ways that I dare not spoil while also revealing the inner workings of their own production that essentially drag the subjects into the court of public opinion in the middle of the movie. In doing so, “You Can See Everything” becomes the rare documentary that does not capture reality but rather, takes reality apart right in front of us. When you see Elizabeth Holmes in long shot at the end, it becomes the version of another Christmas card, leaving you to wonder whether despite having seen so much if you even saw anything real at all.

















