' ' Cinema Romantico: Good One
Showing posts with label Good One. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Good One. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 04, 2026

If I Had Legs I’d Kick You


When the credits rolled on “If I Had Legs I’d Kick You,” I noticed that Josh Safdie, of the erstwhile Safdie Brothers, served as one of the producers. That felt right to me because the preceding 114 minutes felt like an unrelenting, claustrophobic, close-up heavy Safdie-like joint. That is not to divest writer/director Mary Bronstein of her auteurist imprint. Bronstein made “Yeast” in 2008, back when the Safdies were just starting out, and it, too, was an unrelenting, claustrophobic, close-up heavy joint. I say all this to contextualize what you go through in watching “If I Had Legs I’d Kick You,” which is not about addicts, or petty criminals, or a fanatical table tennis player, but a mother, the hardest job in the world. That’s sort of what Bronstein’s movie is, a dramatic thriller about motherhood, starring Rose Byrne as Linda, taking care of a young daughter with a feeding disorder that necessitates virtual round-the-clock care. Bronstein chooses never to show Linda’s daughter in a full shot, reducing her almost entirely to a voice. That choice is disorienting and effective, as if taking the notion of an unbreakable bond between mother and daughter and shattering it, amplified through the frequently intense close-ups of Linda and the cacophonous, unrelenting sound of her daughter’s voice, evoking the strange feeling of loneliness that comes on from never ever having the chance to be alone.

Linda is virtually on her own as a caretaker because her husband Charles is a ship captain who is always away at sea. Stop and think about that for a second. It’s funny, albeit in the darkest way possible and as such, indicative of the darkly comical streak coursing through “If I Had Legs I’d Kick You,” one furthered in Linda’s occupation as a therapist, dispensing psychoanalysis even as both the script and Byrne cultivate the air of someone who looks like she’s on the couch even while she’s in the chair. She finds herself treating a new mother, Caroline (Danielle Macdonald), suffering from postpartum depression and an absent husband, and who thinks Linda is failing to meet her needs just as Linda herself receives treatment from a colleague (Conan O’Brien) who she is convinced is failing to meet her needs. A rare foray into legitimate acting, O’Brien is quite good, though in so many ways, Bronstein helps to sculpt his performance. By yoking the movie so resolutely to Linda’s point-of-view, it is difficult to surmise her reliability as a narrator, and how much her colleague’s brusque, even dismissive, attitude is the reality of what is occurring of merely her perception. “What is it you’re so sure I can’t help you with?” he asks at one point, a breathtaking moment that feels like a moment where we might be seeing him unadorned…but we can’t be sure.

That unreliability extends to the hole that opens in the ceiling of Linda’s apartment, flooding the place, and forcing her and her daughter to evacuate to a seedy motel. She keeps returning to the apartment, anyway, transfixed by the hole, and whether this is pure symbolism or something more supernatural is a question that Bronstein is content to leave unexplained. Those dueling sensations coalesce in Byrne’s mesmerizing turn, in equal measure conveying realism and madness, comedy and horror, and inviting as much disdain as empathy; you don’t necessarily like the destructive decisions she’s making even if you understand why she’s making them. Whether you take the conclusion to be real or imaginary, it can’t help but feel telegraphed, from a thousand movies before it as much as “If I Had Legs I’d Kick You” nodding toward it the whole way. It also doesn’t much matter because Byrne sweeps you up and carries you along, making it feel as if Linda herself is being swept along by some unstoppable current, increasingly unable to fight against it, as if no longer living life but left wholly at its mercy. 

Monday, April 28, 2025

The Room Next Door


What kind of hospital room has a designer olive green sofa? I suppose the same sort of hospital room that has a view of the Manhattan skyline and a festive floral painting on the wall, the sort of hospital room glimpsed in “The Room Next Door.” I am not nitpicking. No, director Pedro Almodóvar is nothing if not the master of modern melodrama, and though we tend to think of melodrama as an exaggeration of characters, emotions, and situations, in his hands, melodrama is an exaggeration of stuff too. That exaggerated stuff takes on an almost spiritual dimension in Almodóvar’s 25th feature film and first in the English language. After all, “The Room Next Door” is about a terminally ill woman, Martha (Tilda Swinton), who asks an old friend who has just re-entered her life, Ingrid (Julianne Moore), to accompany her to a luxurious rental pad in upstate New York to be take up position in the room next door where Martha plans to take control of her ultimate demise by taking her own life. 

Loosely based (by all accounts, I have not read it) on a Sigrid Nunez novel, Almodóvar is less concerned with the ethics of this dramatic situation, essentially starting from a place of death being a personal situation and a personal decision. Establishing that straight away frees “The Room Next Door” to focus on the morals, of one friend putting the genuine request of the other friend first, an idea that comes alive in Moore’s performance, a true blow burn, fiery but quietly fiery. The emergent investigative subplot with a skeptical detective (Alessandro Nivola) has nothing to do with ferreting out the truth, since we already know it, and more to do with Ingrid defining her own sense of decency and truth. More than that, even, “The Room Next Door” is a contrast of light and dark, of finding the desire to go on when it’s literally hopeless to. 


One might draw parallels to our current world. In fact, Almodóvar does, at least in one scene in which Damian (John Turturro), a friend and former lover to both women, notes an overriding sensation of hopelessness in the face of climate change only to be challenged by Ingrid in the face of what she’s seen being at Martha’s side. Given that it’s the only real time this subject is broached, and that Damian never feels as emotionally integrated to the narrative, it plays a little too much like a septuagenarian movie director decrying someone who is, forgive me, woke than a genuine philosophical back and forth. More’s the pity because otherwise, in the colorful world that “The Room Next Door” presents, in its finely calibrated production and costume design, from that olive green couch to Martha’s array of cozy sweaters and comfy looking soft pants, “The Room Next Door” innately expresses feeling comfort and joy in the moment and finding the wherewithal to meet your maker with the perfectly chosen lipstick on your face. 

Is it strange that the most moving moment to me in the whole movie was the one when Ingrid and Martha go to Lincoln Center to see a movie? And Ingrid suggests that, hey, they better go find some seats? If I had a terminal illness, I thought, I would probably want to go see a movie too. And I would probably want to have the best seats in the house.

Wednesday, February 26, 2025

Juror #2


Twelve jurors repair to the deliberation room and take an initial vote on the defendant’s guilt or innocence. All of them seem to lean toward guilt, save for one, “Juror #2,” Justin Kemp (Nicholas Hoult), his trepidation emphasized by the heroic figure he cuts, hands on hips, gazing out a window. It evokes the window motif of Sidney Lumet’s celebrated “12 Angry Men” (1957), though Kemp does not quite evoke Henry Fonda’s Juror #8, the one who insists on seeking the truth. Without spoiling anything, suffice to say that Clint Eastwood’s 40th feature film is not about seeking the truth because it reveals the truth almost straight away. Instead, “Juror #2” becomes something more like a courtroom thriller as excruciating moral dilemma that deftly manages to bring itself to a conclusion without giving a definitive answer to the knotty questions it raises. And even if Jonathan Abrams’s screenplay is cloying enough to make the prosecuting attorney’s name Faith (Toni Collette), and even if it relies on a fair number of plot and character contrivances to keep it running, these are effortlessly papered over not just by the performances (I especially liked how grudging Collette makes her character’s turn away from careerism) but by the 94-year-old Eastwood’s patented just-the-facts filmmaking approach. Essentially, “Juror #2” takes the old E.M. Forster observation that “If I had to choose between betraying my country and betraying my friend, I hope I should have the guts to betray my country” and then ruthlessly dissects it bit by bit, rendering a portrait of a key American institution that ultimately is only as good and trustworthy as the complicated people within it.

Wednesday, February 12, 2025

Good One


Constructed more out of incident and emotion than plot, “Good One” brings to mind Kelly Reichardt’s “Old Joy” (2006) in so much as it is about two lifelong male friends, in this case Chris (James Legros) and Matt (Danny McCarthy), taking a camping trip in the wilderness. The crucial difference, however, is that writer/director India Donaldson’s movie is seen not from their perspective but that of Chris’s queer 17-year-old daughter Sam (Lily Collias) who winds up alone in the company of these two men when Matt’s son backs out at the last minute, resentful over his parents’ divorce. Sam harbors resentments about her own parents’ divorce, it turns out, and, in this case, nature proves not a respite from the larger world but an unmasking of it, opening Sam’s eyes in new and profound ways. She dotes on the men, cooking them dinner, and plays referee to their various spats, and yet, just as often seems to disappear from view, such as in a sequence where they briefly mingle with three other male campers, and in another one when she attends to feminine issues behind a tree trunk while Chris and Matt impatiently wait. 

When Chris cites having children as the last step to emotional maturity sitting next to a daughter who essentially takes care of him the whole trip, Donaldson lets the brutal irony quietly sit there on Sam’s face. And that’s where this movie mostly takes place – on Sam’s face. She is rarely allowed to speak for herself, cut off or ignored when she does, and provided no accompanying voiceover to explicate her thoughts, just occasional texts back home to her girlfriend when she’s in cell range. Indeed, what’s so impressive is that despite Donaldson being a first-time feature director and this being only Collias’s second feature film, they possess an implicit understanding of the actor and camera yoked together, how little both need to do and how that dissolves the barrier between them so that it’s as if her internal monologue is silently beamed straight to us. The men prattle on and on, but Sam doesn’t need to use her words to let us hear everything she thinks.