' ' Cinema Romantico: Robert Altman
Showing posts with label Robert Altman. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert Altman. Show all posts

Friday, July 24, 2026

Friday's Old Fashioned: McCabe & Mrs. Miller (1971)

Robert Altman’s revisionist western “McCabe & Mrs. Miller” has one of the greatest movie character introductions: a solitary figure virtually hidden beneath an enormous fur coast astride a horse in the Pacific Northwest circa 1902. When the figure finally reaches its destination of a rugged mining town, it dismounts and removes the coat. You expect, say, Tom Hardy as a neanderthal-like mountain man and instead, Warren Beatty emerges. He is John McCabe, wearing a suit, albeit a bit rumpled given the circumstances, and dons a derby hat, tipping it to a passerby, cutting the image of a displaced dapper gentleman. The town is named Presbyterian Church, but its central gathering place is the saloon, not the chapel, where McCabe promptly heads, throws a cloth over the table, as if seeking to class up the joint a little, and fires up a card game to start making some money. The saloon owner, Patrick Sheehand (René Auberjonois), approaches, asking if they go into business together by working out a cut of the proceeds, but McCabe begs off. The scene is infused with Altman’s patented style of overlapping dialogue, myriad conversations happening at once, and has the effect of establishing the town itself existing independently of McCabe while simultaneously imbuing the sense that McCabe exists always at center of his own universe.


His universe is thrown for a loop when he purchases three women and opens a brothel, one that only starts turning a profit, however, when the recently arrived Cockney madam Constance Miller (Julie Christie) convinces him to make her a partner and let her run the place since it’s clear his business acumen lags behind his braggadocio. Indeed, Beatty gives an exemplary performance of a man putting on airs who almost, but not quite, knows he is putting on airs and which pairs perfectly with Christie’s raw candor; there’s this thing she does with her face, occasionally twisting it into a kind of confounded grimace, not able to fathom this blustery half-imbecile before her. When they sit down for breakfast to hash out the details of their partnership, Mrs. Miller orders almost as much as Daniel Day-Lewis in “Phantom Thread,” though it’s not a come-on as it was in that 2017 movie but a throwing down, leaving McCabe to look on like a lost little boy. He might become attracted to her, and she to him, but when they eventually wind up in bed together, Altman’s camera drifts away from them and to Mrs. Miller’s dresser where he has put the cash to pay for her time, as funny and sardonic a shot as you’ll see. 

“McCabe & Mrs. Miller” is all business. Even the rumor that he McCabe a gunfighter of some renown known as Pudgy McCabe, which is eventually called into question, comes to feel mostly like a matter of branding. McCabe might claim to have poetry in him, but we don’t hear any of it. The world that Altman cultivates in the dim interiors and frequently harsh exteriors, a town with mud for streets and lumber stacked high is still in the process of building itself, is one that does not make room for poetry. Merely surviving day to day is the highest priority. That becomes an open question for McCabe when the powerful mining company with a hold on the town dispatches a couple representatives to try and buy out McCabe & Mrs. Miller’s successful operation. And though “The Art of the Deal” might not have been published until seven decades later, McCabe proves its ideas are timeless, spurning the initial entreaties as a negotiating tactic to get a bigger payout, only to peeve the negotiators and wind up with three men sent to kill him in lieu of any further bargaining. Art of the deal, indeed.

In another movie, this might be the moment when McCabe finds something within himself that he did not know he had to become a hero. That very notion is mocked by having McCabe meet with a politically ambitious lawyer (William Devane) who suggests taking the mining company to court, sticking it to large corporations and making McCabe a hero of small business owners everywhere, an idea that McCabe quite likes, even repeating it to Mrs. Miller. She looks at him like his days are numbered. He can’t stop what’s coming, though there will be no quick draw or ten paces, foreshadowed in one of the hired guns, a sadistic kid (Manfred Schulz), killing a goofy innocent (Keith Carradine) just to kill him. There is no gallantry here, just gutless desperation, and the ensuing shootout between McCabe and the three men is as funny as it is tragic with our nominal hero mislaying his shotgun and having it confiscated by a minister, of all people, stopping off for a beer and a bump midway through, scurrying around in the falling snow, and shooting people in the back. As it plays out, the Presbyterian church catches on fire, causing the town folk to rally together to save it, a sly juxtaposition to the gunfight that only emphasizes its meaningless. As the town is saved, McCabe winds up dead in the snow and Mrs. Miller winds up in a drug-induced stupor, just one more failed business venture, the American Dream brutally reconstituted as an opium haze. 

Friday, November 07, 2025

Friday's Old Fashioned: Brewster McCloud (1970)

“Brewster McCloud” was the result of a familiar Hollywood scenario in which a filmmaker (Robert Altman) hits it so big (M.A.S.H.) that he receives carte blanche from the moneybags-that-be with his next movie. Even by those standards, though, the maverick Altman swung for the fences. Indeed, the original screenplay by Doran William Cannon, heavily revised by the director, was set in New York but moved to Houston, much of it taking place in and around the Astrodome, the so-called Eighth Wonder of the World, a monument to an American kind of excess destined to eventually go bust. “Brewster McCloud” begins with a bang, concludes with a bigger bang, and in-between exists as a wild, wandering satire of a country it can’t quite bring itself to believe in, maybe portending the 70s, maybe just responding to what was in the air. In opens with a deliberate Frank Debrin-ish recitation of the National Anthem by Daphne Heap, who is played by Margaret Hamilton, who was The Wicked Witch of the West, which Altman makes explicit by putting her in ruby slippers, giving way to a performance by the Merry Clayton of “Lift Every Voice and Sing,” the Black national anthem, and reminding us how good our national anthem could be, never mind our country.


Is it any wonder the eponymous Brewster McCloud (Bud Cort) has taken to a fallout shelter beneath the Astrodome where, aided by something like a revisionist Clarence Odbody, a guardian angel (Sally Kellerman) who seems to have lost her wings, he goes about building his own mechanical wings to take flight like a bird and escape all this mess. Costumed in a red and white striped shirt that evokes Where’s Waldo, Brewster never quite entirely takes flight as a true character himself. He often recedes into the background of a movie in which he’s nominally in the foreground, with Cort’s deliberately standoffish air never taking hold of the screen like Shelley DuVall as his unlikely kinda, sorta love interest, demonstrating in her inaugural onscreen role that she just seemed to arrive onscreen intact in her one-of-a-kind eccentric air.

Then again, in the parallel sequences of an unnamed professor (René Auberjonois) rattling on and on about birds, these monologues essentially describing the behavior of Brewster, it’s a little like he’s in a National Geographic special, a specimen being observed. And he’s a specimen stranded in a world of ignoramuses, racists, and elites. Altman doesn’t let us simply work that out for ourselves; he makes it as pointed as possible, highlighted in how he calls these, shall we say, deplorables out by having bird poop repeatedly fall on them from above, ravens as sort of spiritual hecklers, calling strikes and balls on the playing God phonies below.

The denouement, though, in which Brewster does take to the air with his artificial wings is limited to the Astrodome’s interior, meaning that despite the initial free-feeling nature of the scene, undergirded with inspiring music, he’s still a caged bird. Even then, I wasn’t quite ready for the utterly dark turn this moment takes, joy giving way to agony giving way to horror. And if I wasn’t quite ready for it, I was even less ready for how the utterly dark turn took another turn right back into joy, albeit a brutally ironic kind of joy, deriding breaking the fourth wall to essentially invite us into the horror, a beautifully bewildering coda. It’s nothing new, of course, both before and after “Brewster McCloud,” to equate our society with a bloodthirsty circus crowd but rarely have I seen it conveyed with such manic rage. 

Friday, April 03, 2015

Friday's Old Fashioned: Come Back to the Five and Dime, Jimmy Dean, Jimmy Dean (1982)

“You mean you regret it?” a character is asked in Robert Altman’s “Come Back To The Five Dime, Jimmy Dean Jimmy Dean.” The character replies: “Only when I think about it.” It’s a variation of the immortal riposte by “Chinatown’s” Jake Gittes when asked if his cut-up nose hurts – “Only when I breathe,” he says. Both of these lines possess strident pessimism, of course, but the latter expresses a pained acceptance of it whereas the former is a strict manifestation of denial. The almost entirely female ensemble of Robert Altman’s film, which is based on a stage play he also helmed, is withering on the vine of denial because they, to paraphrase Garrison Keillor, believe in looking reality straight in the eye and telling it what to go do with itself. I don’t make that Keillor reference lightly. After all, Altman also helmed, years later, the cinematic manifestation of “A Prairie Home Companion” and the Five and Dime of “Come Back” may as well be a Lone Star version of Lake Wobegon’s Chatterbox Café, a place where locals get together to shoot the breeze, likely as a means to deliberately ignore the howling winds of desolation.


This collective notion of refusal to acknowledge life’s reality is given a face in the form of James Dean. After all, he came to film “Giant” in Marfa which is but a scant 62 miles away from McCarthy, Texas which is where a few female friends have created a fan club to the original rebel without a cause called The Disciples Of James Dean. They have pictures on the wall, a budget – well, they had a budget ‘til they spent it on matching jackets. Of course, not long after, Jimmy Dean meets his maker in a fiery car wreck. That, it would seem, is not only the night their gang disbanded, but the night the lights went out on the ladies’ respective perceptions of the real world. Now they have re-gathered twenty years later at the five and dime to rehash memories.

“Come Back To The Five & Dime, Jimmy Dean Jimmy Dean” was based on a stage play, one that Altman directed, and it shows, what when considering the film is strictly contained to one locale, the store of the title. Ah, but Altman, it goes without saying, was an exemplary cinematic craftsman, and this film merely re-illuminates it. Sure, the pictures themselves aren’t particularly illuminating given that he shot the film quickly and cheaply on Super 16 before blowing it up to 35mm. The Netflix DVD on which I watched it was chock full of fairly scuzzy images, almost Dust Bowl-ish, which, frankly, only add to the film’s burned out atmosphere. Frames don’t have to pretty to be function effectively.

More crucial, however, is Altman’s maneuvering between past and present, which happens repeatedly and often concurrently. Rather than simply employing basic editing to make the time-jumps, he erected a second set separated from the first set by two way mirrors. It’s a legitimately brilliant decision that allows the characters to literally see themselves in flashback, evoking the idea of lingering in memories in an awesomely tangible way. Films these days so often drop softly lit flashbacks into the midst of present day scenes, but Altman achieves the same effect without ever leaving the current shot. It’s not only a logistical triumph, it’s a means of making the past that much more incredibly immediate. And because the actors are seen long-ago as the same age they are now, it works to underscore that way in which our recollections in our mind don’t always account for the physical changes we underwent.


Each character harbors a secret of one sort or another, varying in level of shock. And although Joanne (Karen Black) might have the most shocking reveal, the most vital reveal is the one that all the other characters already know full well – that is, Mona (Sandy Dennis) pervading the myth her son was sired by Jimmy Dean himself. The whole story of how it happened, and the girls get Mona to recount it one more time, is ludicrous, and it’s supposed to be. It’s a tall tale – a humongous tall tale – and she recites it yet again with such devout passion that you can tell she has really hypnotized herself into believing it. Of course, this reunion will call her on the carpet, and so it does for everyone else as the whole film devolves into a series of melodramatic confessional monologues.

The play, it would appear, was not well received, and that’s understandable. So much of the dialogue is so overwrought that I can’t imagine any stage set, however stylized, could have possibly allowed for it. But here, on Altman’s majestically grimy movie set, one designed by David Gropman, it all feels right at home, true and mind-bogglingly far-fetched all at once. Every metaphor comes at us like the Jesus picture over the bar awash in neon. Outside the door, storm clouds gather in the distance in the hope of bringing rain that will cure the area’s drought, a ham-fisted emblem of the alleviation of everything they have repressed.

Then again, what if the storm just laughs and passes right on by?