' ' Cinema Romantico: To the Wonder
Showing posts with label To the Wonder. Show all posts
Showing posts with label To the Wonder. Show all posts

Monday, November 25, 2013

Giving Thanks For...Olga Kurylenko's Pirouettes

“I doubt there’s a critic out there who managed to get through a review of ‘To the Wonder’ without at least one use of the verb to twirl, given that it’s Kurylenko’s character’s principal form of locomotion throughout the movie. I lost count of the number of individual revolutions she completed while walking through wheat fields, suburban tract housing, and the Tuileries Gardens at around 80.” – Dana Stevens, Slate 

When Ryan McNeil of the Matineecast asked for his listeners to express cinematic thanks in relation to 2013, I tossed off a brief mishmash of a list, topping it with Olga Kurylenko’s pirouettes in “To the Wonder.” I am mighty thankful for Olga Kurylenko’s pirouettes in “To the Wonder.” Upon mentioning this particular blessing on his podcast, Ryan admitted he was more than a little fed up with all of Olga Kurylenko’s pirouettes in “To the Wonder”, and, as the above quote evinces, this does not make him the minority.


It’s possible that to many critics, many of whom have long fawned over reclusive auteur Terrence Malick’s infamously poetic, painterly style, “To the Wonder”, his 2013 offering to the cinema gods, jumped the shark. Just how many rambling abstract voiceovers and sweeping shots of glowing vistas and fields of wheat can one man serve before even the most quixotic critic is reduced to illogical babbling a la Klaus Kinski at the end of “Aguirre, Wrath of God”? Writing in the New Yorker as only he can, David Denby laments that “A Malick sequence has now become a collection of semi-disconnected shots, individually ravishing but bound together by what feels like the trivial narcissism of Caribbean-travel ads on TV.” Exquisite images for the sake of exquisite images.

As someone who has mostly been fond of Malick’s work, I confess that “To the Wonder” worked on me more strongly than any of his previous films. I felt not only swept up in the images, but entirely in tune to their intent. I saw a first fifteen minutes in which Ben Affleck and Olga Kurylenko (whose characters have names although I will refrain from using them because essentially Malick relies on the essence of Affleck and Kurylenko to cultivate the characters) visit Mont St. Michel as a transcendent hymn to the wonder of the title, life in full bloom, flawless harmony between love and nature and the cosmos, and the sort of filmmaking that makes me want to spontaneously combust into cartwheels right there in the theater.

The remainder of the film, however, was a free-fall, Ben and Olga drifting further and further away from the shore of Mont St. Michel, trying desperately to reclaim the wonder and failing. In many respects I found the film’s remaining ninety-five minutes a frustrating slog, and yet that’s exactly what I appreciated about it.

Upon it ending in theater where I first saw it, a girl sitting one seat down asked the guy with her what he thought of the film. He replied that he was with it at the beginning but eventually it lost him. At that, I wanted to wave my arms and shout: “Exactly! Because they were in tune to the wonder of life at the beginning and then they lost it! Don’t you see how brilliant that is?!” But then as frustrating as the film after that opening, I was not entirely lost. And I was not lost because of Olga Kurylenko’s pirouettes.


A couple months ago I became obsessed with Katy Perry’s “Roar.” It wasn’t quite the same sort of obsession I’ve had with other songs where the need to hear it has been nearly narcotic. I would only turn “Roar” when I needed a pick-me-up, and not a pick-me-up on account of withdrawal, as if it were musically bombastic caffeine. If I felt a little low, disconnected, out of touch, monotone, I’d put on the headphones and the click heralding play also heralded a re-connection. Believe me, I know how that sounds, labeling the formal arena rock bubblegum of Katy Perry as a recurring scenic point on this yawning interstate of life. I’m fairly certain I drove a few people close to me batty with my incessant “Roar”ing. Kinda like how so many viewers were driven batty by Olga Kurylenko’s incessant pirouetting.

Of course, what I saw in those pirouettes was the same thing I heard in “Roar.” Yes, she twirled beneath the yawning Oklahoma prairies, but she also twirled down the aisle at the supermarket. No one that’s actually been to the supermarket twirls down the aisle because going to supermarket is a duty bound toil filled with too many people and too many carts in too small a space to gather and purchase all the boring necessities constituting blah mile markers that blend together. So, the signal fading, she twirls, merely a melodramatic way for Olga to re-connect when the transmission is lost.

Olga has a line, recited in voiceover (obviously), in the film's first few minutes that goes like this: "You lifted me from the ground. Brought me back to life." In the course of everyday life we all die a dozen, two dozen, maybe even a hundred thousand, little deaths, and we have to be brought back to (real) life. So we pirouette, we "Roar", this, that, or something else.

This Thanksgiving, remember to raise a glass to your own pirouette.

Sunday, April 21, 2013

To the Wonder

“Where are we when we’re there? Why not always?” 

There is a remarkable shot in the early going of legendary recluse and suddenly (by his standards) prolific auteur Terrence Malick’s latest film "To the Wonder" when Marina (Olga Kurylenko) appears to walk on water. She is not walking on water, of course, and the film does not try to trick us into thinking she is walking on water, instead making it quite clear she is tiptoeing along stones on the edge of the sea. But then the sea gently laps in, momentarily erasing the stones from view, and there is Marina…..gliding. It is not Christ-like, it is something else. It is saying: to experience love, true, uninhibited, overwhelming love, even if it is fleeting, is to feel, but for an instant, as if you are walking on water.


The breathless first fifteen minutes of "To the Wonder" mix swooping images of astonishing beauty in both nature and physical human contact with whispered voiceovers that tell us everything and nothing. The cleansing rush we feel is the cleansing rush they feel – that is, Marina and Neil (Ben Affleck), an American on vacation in France, who meets the beguiling Ukrainian divorcee, living in Paris, which results in a whirlwind if spellbinding courtship. Generally all we receive here are impressions of what is happening but their affection for one another is unmistakable. We do not need to be told what is happening because Malick lets us feel it. This is cinema of almost inexpressible grace and power, it is a sacrament To the Wonder of love.

Neil invites Marina and her ten year old daughter Tatiana (Tatiana Chiline) to return with him to the United States, to his home in Oklahoma, and they accept. The contrasts on display from Europe to America are stark but, of course, Malick being Malick, still ring with the same rarefied beauty. Whether it is the Seine or a Sonic Drive In, he renders each image as if it belongs on a canvas.  Life, as it must, grows more complicated. Marina and Tatiana in their dress and mannerisms, their constant pirouetting in the tall Oklahoma weeds or in the fluorescent aisles of colossal supermarket stores, often seem far from their own shore, unhappy pilgrims yearning to re-cross the Atlantic. Neil, we sense, is less than an ideal mate beyond a romantic getaway. Notice how Malick continually frames Affleck with his back to the camera, as if long ago he turned his back on the world, as if he harbors personal demons for which he has yet to offer penance.

This might be enough to sustain a film for a mere mortal but, again, Malick being Malick, he adds an alluring friend from Neil’s youth, Jane (Rachel McAdams), who comes and goes almost like a windswept apparition (even now I wonder, did I dream that Rachel McAdams was in this film?) as well as a Catholic priest, Father Quintana, played by Javier Bardem in what is no doubt the Sean Penn Memorial "Tree Of Life" Award (given to the character in a Malick movie whose part was clearly pared down in editing). He could have wandered across the Atlantic with Neil and Marina from an Ingmar Bergman movie, suffering from and internally raging against a perceived absence of God. Jane factors into the main story prominently in her own less-than-prominent way but Father Quintana merely tangentially interacts with our primary characters, seeming to exist in a narration entire separate from the one in which we have become invested. It is odd, no doubt, but then Malick has always crafted his films with his heart as opposed to his head and while at its most elementary level it might seem unnecessary consider that Father Quintana, mirroring Neil and Marina’s splintering relationship, has lost all sense of wonder, that intangible mysticism beyond our earthly grasp. 


This is the question Malick abstractly poses again and again as the movie progresses: “Where are we when we’re there? Why not always?” Perhaps this is simplistic, but then I have always admired Malick’s ability and, more crucially, want to not shy away from the most broad and, in turn, grand mysteries of life. And what makes "To the Wonder" such a vexing if celestial conundrum is that rather than building to the wonder itself he positions it upfront at the start, making the remainder of the film a spiritual slog, a confusing struggle to re-connect with a sensation that is hardly possible to understand. You might even check the time. This experience that only a short time ago was so transcendent has turned you into a tragic clockwatcher.

A patron next to me at theater remarked to his companion during the closing credits: “I was with it for that first act and then in the second and third acts it lost me.” Well, exactly! That’s life! You’re in tune with it and then, suddenly, you’re not. What happened? Where did it go? You grapple with it. You try to get it back. Can you get it back? How do you get it back?

I left the theater wrestling with these questions in my mind. I noticed the sky. It was filled with those sorts of stratocumulus clouds that cause the sun to play peek-a-boo. I could not stop looking. I kind of never wanted to stop looking.